An undergraduate on learning from your mistakes—and from one another
“I introduce Tufts as a place where you'll be challenged and there will be people to help you get back up,” said Catie Samaan, Tufts Wilderness Orientation leader and political science and philosophy major. Photo: Alonso Nichols
Freshman fall, I got the worst grade I’ve ever gotten—a C+—on my first essay in Professor Hersh’s American Conservatism class. I called my mom in hysterics and said, ‘I don't know how I got into Tufts; I don't belong here.’ She said, ‘One grade doesn’t define you. You have the opportunity to work harder.’
The next paper was a critique of a reading. I close-read the article a few times. I took my draft to a StAAR Center writing tutor. I went to TA office hours, and I met with Professor Hersh about the essay. If I got another C+ after that, so be it, but I had to know I’d worked hard.
I got an A on that paper.
As a freshman, I attended a lot of Professor Hersh’s office hours, where he’d have in-depth conversations with upperclassmen from our course. I was intimidated to join in, but he’d see me sitting in the back and ask, ‘What do you think about this?’ He does that with everyone. The care and confidence he shows with these invitations testify to Tufts' culture of kindness and academic curiosity.
Last spring, Professor Hersh asked if I’d help with a project to incorporate more viewpoint diversity into gender studies. Gender studies deserves a lot more uptake as a field; there’s a lot of academic content that's valuable for both women and men, especially with the crisis in masculinity among young men. Our goal is to use the research to give everyone a greater understanding of the range of perspectives people hold and invite conversations with and learning from one another.
I’m also a leader for Tufts Wilderness Orientation, which takes first years on a five-day trip throughout New England. I remember the fear of coming to an unfamiliar place, so I take my responsibility very seriously. “I introduce Tufts as a place where you'll be challenged and there will be people to help you get back up.” I tell my first years about my first paper for Professor Hersh ... and that two of my favorite classes have been his. He’s mentored me, he’s written references for me, and I work as a research assistant for him.
It’s not about where you start. It’s the journey (and the people you travel with) that matters.
—Catie Samaan, political science and philosophy major, Class of 2027
Our Tufts is a series of personal stories shared by members of the Tufts community and featured on both Tufts Now and Instagram.